Not that any of you were wondering, but the dealer accidentally gave me an Insight cargo cover instead of the one for the Fit. I didn't notice until I got home but figured as long as I had it, I'd see if it would be at all workable.
It's not

I did learn something: My local dealer sells parts at the window for MSRP but their internet prices are only $5 or so more than the online places. The website says the internet prices are only valid if the parts are shipped to you - no in store pickup, but if you ask nicely they will let you pickup in-store for a $4 service fee.

So it'd be $115 at Bernardi plus $15 ground shipping = $130, my local dealer it was $120 + tax + $4 fee = $131. Only a dollar more, plus no waiting for shipping and a mistake like getting the wrong part only requires a quick drive across town instead of having to ship it back.

YMMV, but it doesn't hurt to ask.