Rev Hang in 5MTs?
#1
Rev Hang in 5MTs?
Has anyone else noticed that the RPMs between shifts actually seem to go up alittle or stay the same when off throttle?
It seems that the Revs do not drop immediately even after letting off the gas in the Fit between shifts like all the other manuals I have owned. I wonder if this rev hang is an issue or just programmed that way.
It seems that the Revs do not drop immediately even after letting off the gas in the Fit between shifts like all the other manuals I have owned. I wonder if this rev hang is an issue or just programmed that way.
#5
haha yeah... you're not imagining things... its in both the GE and GDs... i call it the rev float... lol
if i remember correctly theres a choke point in the clutch line... i remember i posted something about it a while back n did a search and someone said they replaced the slave master cylinder with an Si slave and the float disappeared...
but this is from memory... use the search button or google it...
*edit* i did a quick google because i remember bmw had a similar thing in their clutch line.. CDV, clutch delay valve
if i remember correctly theres a choke point in the clutch line... i remember i posted something about it a while back n did a search and someone said they replaced the slave master cylinder with an Si slave and the float disappeared...
but this is from memory... use the search button or google it...
*edit* i did a quick google because i remember bmw had a similar thing in their clutch line.. CDV, clutch delay valve
Last edited by dela; 02-24-2010 at 01:18 PM.
#8
but my info is from memory... so i could be wrong *shrug*
my question would be... why would petrol need to be efficiently burned while decelerating? for the hypermilers? to slow the deceleration rate?
not trying to prove u wrong.. just something that popped into my head
Last edited by dela; 02-24-2010 at 01:26 PM.
#9
Originally Posted by some googled bmw site
The Clutch Delay Valve (CDV) is a one-way restrictor installed by the factory between the clutch slave cylinder and clutch master cylinder, as shown in Figure 1. It "delays" the engagement of the clutch, much like old record players used a damped tone-arm to gently lower the needle onto the surface of a record.
Because of this valve, no matter how quickly you lift your foot off the clutch pedal, the clutch engages the flywheel at a constant (slow) rate. In theory, it can save the driveline from shock, were an inexperienced (or immature) driver to dump the clutch at high RPM. But in practice, all it does is prematurely wear out the clutch and turn experienced drivers into people who, despite 20 years of practice, cannot shift gears smoothly. During parallel parking maneuvers, the delay can be infuriating, causing constant clutch slippage. And during hard acceleration, the large amount of clutch slippage can greatly shorten the life of your clutch. During normal, sedate driving, the shift from first into second gear is often jerky, leading passengers to question your skill. As the driver, you can see your passengers' heads bobbing back and forth during every shift! Yes, in their minds, they are laughing at you.
just something about the CDV... sounds very similar to our rev/rpm float
#10
i suppose there is still a decent amount of fuel in the cylinders even after you step off the gas pedal and this function burns up that fuel so it comes out cleaner when it is expelled from the exhaust.
i do remember reading about the clutch delay valve that you wrote about since i'm the owner of a an older BMW and i used to frequent BF and other e30 forums. if memory serves me right, they have a similar purpose for emissions reasons and supposedly smoother shifting. the CDV came before the ECU induced "rev hang" of current cars.
now i'm not sure that it helps me shift smoother since i'm used to the revs dropping immediately on my past manual driving experiences.
i do remember reading about the clutch delay valve that you wrote about since i'm the owner of a an older BMW and i used to frequent BF and other e30 forums. if memory serves me right, they have a similar purpose for emissions reasons and supposedly smoother shifting. the CDV came before the ECU induced "rev hang" of current cars.
now i'm not sure that it helps me shift smoother since i'm used to the revs dropping immediately on my past manual driving experiences.
Last edited by neil patrick harris; 02-24-2010 at 01:38 PM.
#11
i suppose there is still a decent amount of fuel in the cylinders even after you step off the gas pedal and this function burns up that fuel so it comes out cleaner when it is expelled from the exhaust.
i do remember reading about the clutch delay valve that you wrote about since i'm the owner of a an older BMW and i used to frequent BF and other e30 forums. if memory serves me right, they have a similar purpose for emissions reasons and supposedly smoother shifting. the CDV came before the "rev hang" of current cars.
now i'm not sure that it helps me shift smoother since i'm used to the revs dropping immediately on my past manual driving experiences.
i do remember reading about the clutch delay valve that you wrote about since i'm the owner of a an older BMW and i used to frequent BF and other e30 forums. if memory serves me right, they have a similar purpose for emissions reasons and supposedly smoother shifting. the CDV came before the "rev hang" of current cars.
now i'm not sure that it helps me shift smoother since i'm used to the revs dropping immediately on my past manual driving experiences.
yeah... its more of an annoyance for me...
#12
Yeah, what "neil patrick harris" is descibing exactly what I am experiencing. Like the DBW is not closing the throttle when I tell it. Well it must be a Honda emission thing since Z's and my old E36 M3 use dbw as well but don't/didn't have any delay.
Now that you mention it, I have also noticed a considerable response difference in the throttle when accelerating as well. I.E. - If you try to blip the throttle quickly to heal-toe there is also a delay.
If anyone has tried heal-toeing on the fit it is a PAIN! Has anyone been able to do it effectively? I hope someone comes out with a electronic solution!
Now that you mention it, I have also noticed a considerable response difference in the throttle when accelerating as well. I.E. - If you try to blip the throttle quickly to heal-toe there is also a delay.
If anyone has tried heal-toeing on the fit it is a PAIN! Has anyone been able to do it effectively? I hope someone comes out with a electronic solution!
#13
when i blip the throttle while engine compressioning it will back fire like 5 times hahaha it sounds sick! but if i let go of the throttle then hit it again and stay on it, it will only back fire once. but with the intake i made and the custom exhaust i have i dont have that rev hang as bad as before and my car has become way way way more responsive no more lag! hahahah
#14
Yeah, what "neil patrick harris" is descibing exactly what I am experiencing. Like the DBW is not closing the throttle when I tell it. Well it must be a Honda emission thing since Z's and my old E36 M3 use dbw as well but don't/didn't have any delay.
Now that you mention it, I have also noticed a considerable response difference in the throttle when accelerating as well. I.E. - If you try to blip the throttle quickly to heal-toe there is also a delay.
If anyone has tried heal-toeing on the fit it is a PAIN! Has anyone been able to do it effectively? I hope someone comes out with a electronic solution!
Now that you mention it, I have also noticed a considerable response difference in the throttle when accelerating as well. I.E. - If you try to blip the throttle quickly to heal-toe there is also a delay.
If anyone has tried heal-toeing on the fit it is a PAIN! Has anyone been able to do it effectively? I hope someone comes out with a electronic solution!
picture just for fun
Last edited by dela; 02-24-2010 at 04:21 PM.
#15
Definitely designed that way thanks to the clutch delay valve. i've noticed that it happens when lugging it around and shifting lower in the rpm range, As long as i'm at least semi-winding it out, no rpm hanging. it's still pretty annoying though and would love a real solution on how to remove/replace it.
#18
Has anyone else noticed that the RPMs between shifts actually seem to go up alittle or stay the same when off throttle?
It seems that the Revs do not drop immediately even after letting off the gas in the Fit between shifts like all the other manuals I have owned. I wonder if this rev hang is an issue or just programmed that way.
It seems that the Revs do not drop immediately even after letting off the gas in the Fit between shifts like all the other manuals I have owned. I wonder if this rev hang is an issue or just programmed that way.
#20
Hear, Hear! Emissions do drive this, a rapidly closed throttle does not scavenge well and has a steep spike in certain emissions components. The rev hang also makes shifting a little smoother for less-skilled drivers, probably keeps the engine mounts healthier longer as well. The behavior of Honda's drive-by-wire is another reason I picked my Fit with my first AT for a daily driver.
I don't know if any of the throttle controllers affect this. Anyone out there with one to confirm/deny?
I don't know if any of the throttle controllers affect this. Anyone out there with one to confirm/deny?