1st gen totalled. Shopping. Is 2nd gen better?
#1
1st gen totalled. Shopping. Is 2nd gen better?
hi you all, as you know my 1st gen was totalled by a hit and run just over three weeks ago. I'm shopping for a car. What's better/worse about the 2nd gen? I don't care about looks. I'm interested in driving, esp highway, and any quirks reliability maintenance issues that the 09 or 10 has that I need to know about?
#2
We had two 2nd gens. Never did anything to them other than fuel oil changes and tires. Now have a 3rd gen. which is basically the same car with a few new new features. We would still have the 2nd gen ones (a 2009 and 2011) if my daughter hadn't totaled both of them. A 45 mph head on with a van and a deer strike at 55 mph did them both in.
#3
"Better" is kind of subjective.
I never owned a Gen 1 Fit, so can't make a comparison.
But I would say, I owned a Gen 2, 2010 Honda Fit and thought it was well built, reliable and fun to drive.
Also, IMO there are significant differences between Gen 2 and Gen 3. The Gen 3 offers more amenities....in the EX a sunroof, but for good or bad, it also feels more refined, softened.
Also, the interior of the Gen 3 is IMO much more homogenized, it's a very nice dash, and interior, but very standard looking. While I thought the over sized dials, and sloping dash of the Gen 2 Fit was much more unique.
But I realize that is not the comparison shopping the OP is doing.
I can only say, I wouldn't hesitate to buy a Gen 2, If you were happy with your Gen 1 Fit, I would say, I bet you would be happy with a Gen 2.
The choice is however yours.
I never owned a Gen 1 Fit, so can't make a comparison.
But I would say, I owned a Gen 2, 2010 Honda Fit and thought it was well built, reliable and fun to drive.
Also, IMO there are significant differences between Gen 2 and Gen 3. The Gen 3 offers more amenities....in the EX a sunroof, but for good or bad, it also feels more refined, softened.
Also, the interior of the Gen 3 is IMO much more homogenized, it's a very nice dash, and interior, but very standard looking. While I thought the over sized dials, and sloping dash of the Gen 2 Fit was much more unique.
But I realize that is not the comparison shopping the OP is doing.
I can only say, I wouldn't hesitate to buy a Gen 2, If you were happy with your Gen 1 Fit, I would say, I bet you would be happy with a Gen 2.
The choice is however yours.
#4
Harder to get to the back of the engine in 2nd gen because the wiper motor and cowl are in the way, whereas in the first gen it's much easier access. If you do your own plugs and coilpacks, it'll take more time, but if you don't, doesn't matter.
I think 2nd gen is a little more civilized on the road, less of that go-cart feel, a little quieter and more composed, less buzzy. I drove a 1st gen for almost 150K miles and when I took my first test drive in the 2nd gen after the 1st gen got totaled, the difference was not subtle. I'd take the 2nd gen in a heartbeat for highway driving.
I think 2nd gen is a little more civilized on the road, less of that go-cart feel, a little quieter and more composed, less buzzy. I drove a 1st gen for almost 150K miles and when I took my first test drive in the 2nd gen after the 1st gen got totaled, the difference was not subtle. I'd take the 2nd gen in a heartbeat for highway driving.
#5
I thought my 2010 had more of a Go-Kart on rails feeling. While the 2016, is more refined.
Most of the time I'm happy with the 2016....on full moon nights...I miss the 2010.
#8
Yep, and I have a 3rd gen now, with a CVT, after my last seven cars were all manual. The difference between the 2nd gen AT and the 3rd gen CVT was huge - the 2nd gen AT was harsh and buzzy going through the first couple gears, whereas the CVT is smooth and quiet in comparison, and keeps the revs much lower.
#10
2nd gen is most definitely better than the GD.. but that's if you get the MT. i hated the AT on my 09 GE my wife drove. the 12 GE i also had was MT and that was actually a pretty fun car to drive. i hate absolutely zero issues on the '12.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
radioarno
2nd Generation (GE 08-13)
15
02-05-2018 07:18 AM
bulldogtrekker
2nd Generation GE8 Specific Fit Photos & Videos Sub-Forum
1
02-09-2015 02:42 PM
Desmond Lamar MacRae
3rd Generation (2015+)
1
04-05-2014 10:30 PM