So, my mats didn't hold up too well...Can I order just the driver's mat? =)

What other options do you all like? Seems like some like the liners and some like the all weather mats from Weather-Tech?

 

You can't buy just the driver side mat from Honda, but I believe WeatherTech sells them separately for fronts and rears.

 

If you want an inexpensive approach: perhaps contact cement and indoor/outdoor carpeting, using the worn-out mat as a base?

Tractor Supply Company (TSC) and similar stores sell thick rubber matting by the foot that's intended for the floors of horse stalls and such like. It would also make a nice durable surface for the mat that's not all that different from the original:
RB Rubber Multi-Mat Rolled Rubber, 1/4 in. Thick, Sold by the Foot - Tractor Supply Online Store
RB Rubber Multi-Mat Rolled Rubber, 3/8 in. Thick, Sold by the Foot - Tractor Supply Online Store

 

Mine is almost ready to give out too...

I think I need to check the WeatherTech or some aftermarket one.

 

My Honda mats are just sitting here as I went to Weather Techs. I would sell the Honda ones but shipping would be very high.

 

I'd be interested in what you decide to do. I can tell mine are heading the same direction as yours. How many miles did you get on your vehicle before there was the hole?

 

the hole started a while ago, maybe at 50 or 60k?, but replaced at 80k. I just bought new honda ones.