Hi everyone,

I’m trying to figure out a steering/handling issue on my 2011 Honda Fit (around 283,000 km / 176,000 miles) and I’m honestly running out of ideas. I’ve already spent a lot of money trying to diagnose and fix this, so I’d really appreciate some opinions before I continue throwing parts at it.

The main symptom is this:

• On the highway, the car constantly wanders left and right.
  
• I’m always making small steering corrections and counter-corrections.
  
• The steering does not naturally self-center properly.
  
• After turning a corner, the steering wheel often stays partially turned instead of smoothly returning to center.
  
• Sometimes it slowly comes back in small jerky/saccadic movements over several seconds.
  
• If I make a small steering input (for example around 20–30 degrees), the wheel may barely return at all unless I manually bring it back.
  

This makes highway driving extremely tiring.

What confuses me is that this issue used to be intermittent for years. Sometimes the car would feel great, sometimes not. Oddly enough, tire rotations or seasonal tire changes sometimes seemed to improve the issue temporarily, which originally made me suspect wheels or tires.

Last summer, I installed a first set of aftermarket struts (cheaper ones), and surprisingly the car drove very well. I even drove around the Gaspé Peninsula for several thousand kilometers with no major issues.

Then in the fall:

• the suspension started making squeaking/squishing noises,
  
• and I also started noticing more wandering on the highway.
  

The garage replaced those struts under warranty with supposedly higher-quality aftermarket struts. The squeaking disappeared, but the steering/centering problem became MUCH worse over the winter.

At first, the garage suspected the top mounts/strut bearings. They replaced the aftermarket top mounts with OEM Honda top mounts.

Result:

• steering feels slightly smoother in turns,
  
• maybe a small improvement overall,
  
• but the main problem is still there almost entirely.
  

At this point, the steering still does not self-center properly.

Things that have already been checked:

• tie rods
  
• ball joints
  
• bushings
  
• steering intermediate shaft / steering joint
  
• alignment
  
• multiple road tests by different mechanics
  

No mechanic found major play, clunking, or obvious damage.

One mechanic thinks the issue was mostly caused by the top mounts binding.
Another thought maybe slightly stiff steering components.
Nobody has strongly suggested the steering rack yet.

Important detail:

• there are NO major clunks when turning,
  
• no obvious looseness,
  
• no steering rack leaks,
  
• no major vibration,
  
• but the steering return-to-center behavior feels wrong.
  

At this point, I’m trying to understand:

• Can aftermarket struts themselves cause poor self-centering and constant micro-corrections?
  
• Could the struts/springs still be binding even with OEM top mounts?
  
• Could this still be a subtle steering rack issue even without obvious clunking/play?
  
• Has anyone experienced a Honda Fit that became extremely sensitive to suspension brand/setup?
  

I’m hesitant to spend thousands more replacing parts without a clear diagnosis, especially on a high-mileage car.

Any ideas or similar experiences would really help.

Thanks.

 

After everything you've checked and replaced.... I'd start thinking about the steering rack.
At first I was going to say tie rods or control arm bushings. Then maybe it was your choice of tire (directional tires can sometimes feel different than others).
But you're saying you've checked those and confirmed everything is fine.

So if you haven't replaced your steering rack yet, maybe look into that. Even without leaking or clunking, a steering rack could still cause some sort of wander or play when under load and at high speed.

Also, how are your wheel bearings? Test those and make sure they're tight without any side-to-side play.

 

Thanks. That’s actually one of the things confusing me the most.

If it was purely the steering rack, I’m having trouble explaining why the issue used to be intermittent for years, and why tire rotations or seasonal tire changes sometimes seemed to improve it temporarily.

Also, last summer I had a different set of aftermarket struts installed (cheaper ones), and the car actually drove very well. I drove several thousand kilometers around the Gaspé Peninsula with almost no highway wandering and no major steering complaints.

The issue became much worse only after the garage replaced those struts with a supposedly higher-quality set last fall. That’s why I keep wondering whether the current struts/suspension setup is somehow amplifying an existing sensitivity or friction in the steering system.

The poor self-centering is what worries me the most. Even after replacing the top mounts with OEM Honda mounts, the wheel still returns very slowly and sometimes barely returns at all after small turns.

As for wheels/bearings, another important detail is that this spring I actually bought a completely different set of wheels because I originally suspected a bent wheel or wheel-related issue. So the current wheels are basically brand new, which makes this even more confusing.

Wheel bearings are still something I should probably have checked more carefully though.

 

I honestly don't see how the struts would have any impact on your steering unless you aren't using the correct struts. However, I'm not 100% on that.
However, a stiffer strut/spring combination could definitely amplify other issues as you mentioned. So that's not an awful line of thought.

Have you only had one garage/shop look at things for you? A second opinion is definitely warranted, imo. Either from another shop or from a Honda dealer.

But yeah, wheel bearings are easy to check. Watch a Youtube video if you need. But you just have to get one wheel up off the ground to test for each bearing.

 

Yeah, that's pretty much where my thinking is at right now too.


I don't necessarily think the struts alone created the problem from nothing, because I did have some intermittent wandering/sensitivity issues for years before this. Sometimes the car felt perfectly stable, other times not. Tire rotations or seasonal tire changes sometimes seemed to improve things temporarily, which originally made me suspect wheels or tires.

But the current setup definitely made the problem MUCH more noticeable.

The confusing part is that the previous aftermarket suspension setup actually felt pretty good overall. I drove several thousand kilometers with that setup and highway stability was surprisingly good. The major self-centering issue only became obvious after the garage replaced those struts with the current supposedly higher-quality setup.

The garage originally suspected the aftermarket top mounts/bearings were binding, so they recently replaced them with OEM Honda top mounts. Steering feels slightly smoother now, but the poor self-centering issue is still largely there.

Since then, the steering still feels like it wants to stay slightly left or right instead of naturally returning to center.

And yes, I've actually had multiple shops look at it already:

- tie rods checked
- ball joints checked
- bushings checked
- steering intermediate shaft checked
- alignment checked

None of them found obvious play or a major failure.

Also, I even bought a completely different set of wheels this spring because I originally suspected a bent wheel issue. So the current wheels are basically brand new.

At this point I'm honestly trying to figure out whether:

1) the current suspension setup is binding/amplifying something,
2) there is still some subtle steering rack issue,
or 3) it's a combination of both.

The car has around 160k miles now, so I'm also trying to be realistic about how much money makes sense to invest into further diagnosis or repairs. The car is still reliable overall, but the steering behavior becomes very tiring on longer drives.