I did change yesterday, at the Honda dealer, the oil on my Honda
Element 2004.
I asked for Synthetic oil. They did change the oil.
Later I did noticed the oil they put was Castrol, Synthetic, 10W30.
In the Honda Element owner's manual is mentioned to use 5W20
Someone told me later for Synthetic oil I should use special filter
for synthetic oil.

My question is if Honda dealer did OK when they put Castrol oil
instead of genuine Honda oil and filter.

Any comments would be appreciated

 

Would not worry about the brand, my dealer uses Quaker State, but they used
the wrong weight

Do not think synthetic uses a special filter

Gary

"Chris" <criro1961@yahoo.ca> wrote in message
news:f68m81tlpfmg7840ujh1r1bvremuk4nl06@4ax.com...
>I did change yesterday, at the Honda dealer, the oil on my Honda
> Element 2004.
> I asked for Synthetic oil. They did change the oil.
> Later I did noticed the oil they put was Castrol, Synthetic, 10W30.
> In the Honda Element owner's manual is mentioned to use 5W20
> Someone told me later for Synthetic oil I should use special filter
> for synthetic oil.
>
> My question is if Honda dealer did OK when they put Castrol oil
> instead of genuine Honda oil and filter.
>
> Any comments would be appreciated

 

> My question is if Honda dealer did OK when they put Castrol oil
> instead of genuine Honda oil and filter.
>
> Any comments would be appreciated

Your car will be just fine if not better off. Where do you live? It's just
about summer for the entire lower US so you'll definitely be fine! The
slightly thicker oil has less viscosity improvers for the lower spread of
10w-30 and is perfectly adequate for the 2.4 I4 in the Element. You will be
OK by following Hondas 5w-20 recommendation but you will be just as well off
running 5w-30s and 10w30s especially if you want it to be a 'lifer'.

 

I have been using synthetic oil since 1993 on all my vehicles including a
honda accord and honda civic. My manual calls for 5w30. As far as using
Castrol synthectic, that is just fine. I used to use that but switched to
Mobil one synthetic. (personal choice). Both are very good!! My 93 civic
has 280000miles as proof. There is no special filter that I know of for use
with synthetic oil, however some filters are better than others. They just
have better filtering characteristics. Usually the more expensive the
filter the better, but if you regularly change your oil at 3k to 5k miles it
isn't going to make much difference. Just my two cents :)
"Chris" <criro1961@yahoo.ca> wrote in message
news:f68m81tlpfmg7840ujh1r1bvremuk4nl06@4ax.com...
>I did change yesterday, at the Honda dealer, the oil on my Honda
> Element 2004.
> I asked for Synthetic oil. They did change the oil.
> Later I did noticed the oil they put was Castrol, Synthetic, 10W30.
> In the Honda Element owner's manual is mentioned to use 5W20
> Someone told me later for Synthetic oil I should use special filter
> for synthetic oil.
>
> My question is if Honda dealer did OK when they put Castrol oil
> instead of genuine Honda oil and filter.
>
> Any comments would be appreciated

 

I have a 2002 CRV with the same engine as you. Right on the dipstick it
says use 5W20 but when I get a oil change at the dealer they have always
used 10W30.
"Chris" <criro1961@yahoo.ca> wrote in message
news:f68m81tlpfmg7840ujh1r1bvremuk4nl06@4ax.com...
> I did change yesterday, at the Honda dealer, the oil on my Honda
> Element 2004.
> I asked for Synthetic oil. They did change the oil.
> Later I did noticed the oil they put was Castrol, Synthetic, 10W30.
> In the Honda Element owner's manual is mentioned to use 5W20
> Someone told me later for Synthetic oil I should use special filter
> for synthetic oil.
>
> My question is if Honda dealer did OK when they put Castrol oil
> instead of genuine Honda oil and filter.
>
> Any comments would be appreciated

 

Chris wrote:

>
> My question is if Honda dealer did OK when they put Castrol oil
> instead of genuine Honda oil and filter.

Yes Castrol is a good oil. I've used it and Valvoline oil for years.

>
> Any comments would be appreciated

The merits of switching to synthetic lubrication is debatable. You
will see posts here about how this car or that engine went some
unbelievable mileage, and it was due to synthetic oil. Well let me
tell you, the Element's engine was designed to use regular petroleum
lubricants. And if you change it at the recommended intervals, the
engine should last just as long as if you used synthetic oil.
So what's the difference? You'll be paying more for the same
performance. It's your choice if using (paying more) for synthetic
lubricants makes YOU feel better; then use it. Me, I'd rather go out
to dinner on the savings.


--
Tp,

-------- __o
----- -\<. -------- __o
--- ( )/ ( ) ---- -\<.
-------------------- ( )/ ( )
-----------------------------------------

No Lawsuit Ever Fixed A Moron...

 

Sounds like you're okay. Just as a side note, service departments just
started using a different filter for the Element and it does not have near
the filtering capability that the previous filter had. One of the mods on
the Honda Element Owners Club forum did a full analysis of these and several
other filters and it was interesting stuff. His advice was simply to not go
over your schedule recheck/change oil date or mileage. Good luck.

"Chris" <criro1961@yahoo.ca> wrote in message
news:f68m81tlpfmg7840ujh1r1bvremuk4nl06@4ax.com...
>I did change yesterday, at the Honda dealer, the oil on my Honda
> Element 2004.
> I asked for Synthetic oil. They did change the oil.
> Later I did noticed the oil they put was Castrol, Synthetic, 10W30.
> In the Honda Element owner's manual is mentioned to use 5W20
> Someone told me later for Synthetic oil I should use special filter
> for synthetic oil.
>
> My question is if Honda dealer did OK when they put Castrol oil
> instead of genuine Honda oil and filter.
>
> Any comments would be appreciated

 

On Sat, 21 May 2005 14:06:22 GMT, TomP <roadcyc@socal.rr.com> wrote:

>Chris wrote:
>
>>
>> My question is if Honda dealer did OK when they put Castrol oil
>> instead of genuine Honda oil and filter.
>
>Yes Castrol is a good oil. I've used it and Valvoline oil for years.
>
>>
>> Any comments would be appreciated
>
>The merits of switching to synthetic lubrication is debatable. You
>will see posts here about how this car or that engine went some
>unbelievable mileage, and it was due to synthetic oil. Well let me
>tell you, the Element's engine was designed to use regular petroleum
>lubricants. And if you change it at the recommended intervals, the
>engine should last just as long as if you used synthetic oil.
>So what's the difference? You'll be paying more for the same
>performance. It's your choice if using (paying more) for synthetic
>lubricants makes YOU feel better; then use it. Me, I'd rather go out
>to dinner on the savings.
Thanks for comments.
The main raison I choosed for synthetic is I am towing a camping
trailer (in limit) from time to time. People recommend using synthetic
when tow.

Thanks, Chris

 

"Chris" <criro1961@yahoo.ca> wrote in message
news:f68m81tlpfmg7840ujh1r1bvremuk4nl06@4ax.com...
> I did change yesterday, at the Honda dealer, the oil on my Honda
> Element 2004.
> I asked for Synthetic oil. They did change the oil.
> Later I did noticed the oil they put was Castrol, Synthetic, 10W30.
> In the Honda Element owner's manual is mentioned to use 5W20
> Someone told me later for Synthetic oil I should use special filter
> for synthetic oil.
>
> My question is if Honda dealer did OK when they put Castrol oil
> instead of genuine Honda oil and filter.
>
> Any comments would be appreciated

The clearances on the newer engines are tighter, which is why they recommend
the thinner oil. Many Honda dealers use 5W30 or 10W30, because it is
cheaper. My relative has a repair shop, and he uses 5W20 and Honda filters
when he does Hondas, and he buys the oil and filters at the wholesale Honda
parts department. The parts manager was amused, because even the dealership
to which the parts department is attached, doesn't use 5W20, and in some
cases doesn't use Honda filters. You can't buy 5W20 in bulk, delivered to
your oil tank.

As for synthetic, there may not be a 5W20 synthetic.

Many car dealers have one bulk tank of oil, and they fill it with 10W30. My
Toyota says 5W30, but the dealer used 10W30, and I made them change it, as I
would be driving the vehicle into very cold climates.

 

Tighter clearances? I want to see the numbers to prove this. No one
has been able to come up with that on this board.

 

On Wed, 18 May 2005 07:10:48 -0400, Chris <criro1961@yahoo.ca> wrote:

>I did change yesterday, at the Honda dealer, the oil on my Honda
>Element 2004.
>I asked for Synthetic oil. They did change the oil.
>Later I did noticed the oil they put was Castrol, Synthetic, 10W30.
>In the Honda Element owner's manual is mentioned to use 5W20
>Someone told me later for Synthetic oil I should use special filter
>for synthetic oil.
>
>My question is if Honda dealer did OK when they put Castrol oil
>instead of genuine Honda oil and filter.
>
>Any comments would be appreciated
Thanks for all comments

Chris

 

In article <NGGle.8719$M36.1662@newsread1.news.atl.earthlink. net>,
Steven M. Scharf <scharf.steven@linkearth.net> wrote:
>As for synthetic, there may not be a 5W20 synthetic.

Regardless of the merits or not of 5W-20 or of dealers not following
the oil specification in the owner's manual, aren't there 5W-20 synthetic
oils now from Mobil and Castrol?

--
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Timothy J. Lee
Unsolicited bulk or commercial email is not welcome.
No warranty of any kind is provided with this message.

 

"Timothy J. Lee" <remove22@sonic.net> wrote in message
news:d7lg3v$8tf$1@bolt.sonic.net...
> In article <NGGle.8719$M36.1662@newsread1.news.atl.earthlink. net>,
> Steven M. Scharf <scharf.steven@linkearth.net> wrote:
> >As for synthetic, there may not be a 5W20 synthetic.
>
> Regardless of the merits or not of 5W-20 or of dealers not following
> the oil specification in the owner's manual, aren't there 5W-20 synthetic
> oils now from Mobil and Castrol?

Yes, my mistake.

 

<jmattis@attglobal.net> wrote in message
news:1117254602.793512.314210@g49g2000cwa.googlegr oups.com...
> Tighter clearances? I want to see the numbers to prove this. No one
> has been able to come up with that on this board.

The 5W20 is for a reason. Honda would not have gone and annoyed dealers,
independent shops, and DIY owners, if there was not a legitimate reason for
the 5W20. It could be that they simply found that their engines worked
better with 5W20, or that it increased the fuel economy.